There’s something satisfying about dropping whole fruits into a juicer and watching a fresh stream of juice pour out seconds later. I’ve used quite a few centrifugal juicers over the years, but the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth series remains one of the most practical and budget-friendly lines available. Recently, I spent time juicing with both the Hamilton Beach 67601A and the Hamilton Beach 67608A, two models that look very similar at first glance. And while they technically share the same motor, same design philosophy, and even the same features, using them back-to-back made a few differences stand out.
If you’re trying to decide between the two, this deep, real-experience comparison will help you see what actually matters in daily use — not just what’s written on the product page.
Main Difference Between Hamilton Beach 67601A vs 67608A Juicer Machine
The main difference between the 67601A and 67608A is the exterior build and finish:
- 67601A comes in black plastic with a matte finish, lighter and more compact.
- 67608A comes in silver plastic with a sleek stainless-steel-look finish, slightly larger and heavier.
Internally, both have the same:
- 800W motor
- Big Mouth 3-inch feed chute
- Same pulp bin size
- Same dishwasher-safe components
- Same type of strainer and blade
So the real decision comes down to looks, kitchen presence, ease of handling, and how the minor size difference affects usage.
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
Comparison Table:Hamilton Beach 67601A vs 67608A Juicer Machine
| Feature | Hamilton Beach 67601A | Hamilton Beach 67608A |
| Motor Power | 800W | 800W |
| Material | Plastic | Plastic |
| Finish | Matte Black | Silver / Stainless Look |
| Weight | 3800g (~8.3 lbs) | 7.8 lbs |
| Dimensions | 11.5″ x 7.8″ x 14.4″ | 13″ x 9″ x 16″ |
| Feed Chute | 3″ Big Mouth | 3″ Big Mouth |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 3 Years | 3 Years |
| Special Features | Whole fruit chute, removable blade | Whole fruit chute, removable blade |
| Best For | Smaller kitchens, simple design | More premium look, slightly larger capacity |
| Check Latest Price & Deals | Buy on Amazon | Buy on Amazon |
-
Design & Build Feel
The first thing I noticed when unboxing these two juicers is how similar they seem — until you place them side by side.
Hamilton Beach 67601A (Black):
The matte black finish gives it a cleaner, more minimalistic appearance. It feels a bit lighter in hand, and because of its smaller footprint, it fits more comfortably on a cramped countertop. The plastic feels solid enough for everyday juicing, though it doesn’t have that premium “shine.”
Hamilton Beach 67608A (Silver):
The silver finish makes it look like it belongs next to stainless steel appliances. It simply looks more modern. Though still made of plastic, the coating gives it a higher-end vibe. It is slightly bigger, and I felt the extra size when positioning it on the counter, but nothing inconvenient.
Winner (Design): Hamilton Beach 67608A — looks more premium, especially in a modern kitchen.
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
-
Ease of Use
Both juicers share the Big Mouth 3-inch chute, and honestly, that chute is the main reason I love these machines. I could drop whole apples, uncut celery sticks, or big carrots straight in. No chopping. No prep fatigue.
Hamilton Beach 67601A Experience:
This model is very straightforward. It feels like the lighter of the two, so moving it around after cleaning was easier. The locking mechanism snaps firmly, and I had no trouble assembling the pieces even the first time.
Hamilton Beach 67608A Experience:
Operating this one feels exactly the same as the 67601A. Same chute, same locking arm, same push bar. The only difference is that it sits taller, which gave me a little more hand space when placing a cup under the spout.
Winner (Ease of Use): Tie — they operate identically.
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
-
Juicing Performance
Now to the part that matters — the juice.
Both models run on the same 800-watt motor, and they extract juice at the same speed. During my testing, I juiced apples, carrots, celery, oranges, pineapple, and even leafy greens like spinach.
What I experienced with both:
- Hard vegetables come out beautifully.
- Apples and pears juice extremely smoothly.
- Leafy greens do juice, but like most centrifugal machines, the yield is lower compared to a slow juicer.
- Foam is present in both models (normal for centrifugal juicers).
- No choking, no motor strain.
Hamilton Beach 67601A Juicing Feel:
It vibrates slightly less because it’s lighter. I didn’t feel any difference in extraction.
Hamilton Beach 67608A Juicing Feel:
Because of the slightly larger, heavier body, it feels more grounded and stable while running.
Winner (Performance): Tie — there’s no difference in output or speed.
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
-
Pulp Dryness & Juice Yield
Since both models share the same internal components, I expected the pulp levels to be the same — and they were.
Pulp texture on both:
- Slightly damp, normal for centrifugal juicers.
- Hard produce like carrots produced noticeably dry pulp.
- Leafy greens created wetter pulp (expected).
- For everyday juicing, both are excellent for the price.
Winner:
Tie
-
Noise Level
Both are loud — typical centrifugal juicer noise. About the level of a blender.
No difference between the two.
-
Cleaning & Maintenance
This is one of the strongest parts of both models. Everything except the base is dishwasher safe. The included cleaning brush works well on the mesh filter.
Hamilton Beach 67601A Cleaning Thoughts:
Because of its smaller size, rinsing and handling the pulp container felt slightly easier.
Hamilton Beach 67608A Cleaning Thoughts:
The parts are a bit larger, so storing them in the dishwasher required adjusting placement.
Winner (Cleaning): 67601A, only because it’s slightly easier to handle due to its smaller size.
-
Durability & Stability
Hamilton Beach 67601A:
Feels sturdy, but because it’s lighter, it moves a little when juicing very hard produce.
Hamilton Beach 67608A:
The heavier, bulkier design made it sit more firmly on my countertop. Even on full power with tough carrots, it barely budged.
Hamilton Beach 67601A Juicer Machine
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
Pros:
- Lighter and easier to handle
- Smaller footprint fits in compact kitchens
- Affordable and effective
- Very easy to clean
- Powerful 800W motor
- Big Mouth chute saves prep time
Cons:
- Plain plastic appearance
- Slightly less stable when running
Hamilton Beach 67608A Juicer Machine
- AMERICA'S #1 JUICE EXTRACTOR BRAND: This durable juicer is backed by a 3-year limited warranty...
Pros:
- Premium stainless-steel-look finish
- More stable on countertop
- Same excellent performance
- Big capacity pulp bin
- Dishwasher-safe parts
Cons:
- Slightly bulkier
- Takes more storage space
Conclusion: Which Juicer Should You Buy?
After using both juicers repeatedly, I realized the decision really comes down to your kitchen style and handling preferences — not performance, because performance is virtually identical.
Choose 67601A if you want:
- A lighter, compact juicer
- A budget-friendly model
- Quick cleaning and easy handling
- A simple matte black design
Choose 67608A if you want:
- A more premium-looking juicer
- A model that sits more firmly while running
- A silver appliance that matches stainless-steel kitchens
- Slightly more height and a modern aesthetic
If I had to pick just one, I would personally go with the 67608A. The sturdier feel and the more premium exterior simply make it look and behave like a stronger machine, even though the internal performance is the same.
But if budget and compact size matter more, the 67601A is still one of the best-value juicers you can buy today.
